A competency framework for programme directors, teachers and clinical supervisors in postgraduate medical training: A position paper by the committees for personnel and organizational development in teaching (POiL) and postgraduate medical training (WB) of the DACH Association for Medical Education (GMA)
Bernhard Steinweg 1Ulrike Sonntag 2
Friederike Bennett 3
Folkert Fehr 4
Eckhart G. Hahn 5
Thomas Kollewe 6
Raphael Kunisch 7
Eva K. Hennel 8
1 Rheinische Friedrich-Wilhelms-Universität Bonn, Medizinischen Fakultät, Studiendekanat, Bonn, Germany
2 Charité – Universitätsmedizin Berlin, Institut für Allgemeinmedizin, Berlin, Germany
3 University College London, Faculty of Medical Sciences, London, United Kingdom
4 Gemeinschaftspraxen für Kinder- und Jugendmedizin, Sinsheim an der Elsenz, Germany
5 Universitätsklinikum Erlangen, Erlangen, Germany
6 Goethe-Universität Frankfurt, Fachbereich Medizin, Frankfurter Arbeitsstelle für Medizindidaktik, Frankfurt, Germany
7 Universität Augsburg, Universitätsklinikum Augsburg, Medizinische Fakultät, Institut für Allgemeinmedizin, Augsburg, Germany
8 Schweizerisches Institut für ärztliche Weiter- und Fortbildung SIWF/ISFM, Bern, Switzerland
Abstract
Background: Competency-based postgraduate medical training focused on teaching a defined set of competencies rather than on the numbers of hours spent in training or on cases poses new challenges to the teaching skills of physicians authorised to provide postgraduate training (postgraduate medical educators).
Objective: The objective of this position paper is to develop a cross-disciplinary, practice-oriented competency framework for postgraduate medical educators in postgraduate medical training that takes into account the specific conditions of the healthcare system. The competency framework is intended to give postgraduate medical educators an orientation on their qualification profile and to define uniform criteria for assessing the medical educational qualifications of postgraduate medical educators in Germany. A secondary objective is to develop recommendations for the design and practical implementation of competency training.
Method: Within a consensus-building process, a cross-disciplinary working group comprising members of the committees for personnel and organizational development in teaching (POiL) and postgraduate medical training (WB) of the DACH Association for Medical Education (GMA) adapted these competencies to postgraduate medical training curricula. Besides referencing relevant international literature, this process drew on a position paper setting out core competencies for medical education prepared by the GMA’s POiL committee. The process is reported in accordance with the ACCORD guideline.
Result: A core competency framework for postgraduate medical educators has been developed that comprises six competency fields with subcompetencies and learning objectives and incorporates specific practical examples for implementation at postgraduate training sites as well as for teaching train-the-trainer courses. In addition, recommendations were also formulated for the planning and delivery of training courses and for lecturers’ qualifications.
Conclusion: Our competency framework provides a uniform orientational framework for postgraduate medical educators and their qualification needs. The framework allows these competencies to be taught in train-the-trainer courses, put into practice at postgraduate training sites, and evaluated in terms of teaching qualification. There is a need to systematically evaluate and empirically research both its implementation at postgraduate training sites as well as the structure and delivery of educational training by the various state medical associations.
Keywords
personal and organisational development, postgraduate medical training, physicians authorised to provide postgraduate training, designated training supervisors, postgraduate medical educators, teaching, medical education competencies, competency framework, teaching qualification, train-the-trainer courses, entrustable professional activity (EPA)
1. Introduction
The competency-based orientation of postgraduate medical training poses new challenges for physicians authorised to provide postgraduate training, particularly in terms of didactics. Pursuant to a resolution passed by the German Medical Assembly (Deutscher Ärztetag) in 2024, all state medical associations are required to offer appropriate qualification curricula for postgraduate medical educators [1]. In 2025, the German Medical Association also adopted framework recommendations on a continuing professional development measure for postgraduate medical educators [2]. Qualification curricula for teachers are already available at numerous locations in German-speaking countries. Additionally, the recommendations for improving the quality of postgraduate medical training published in the 2015 version of the global standards of the World Federation for Medical Education (WFME) [3] are now also available in German and take into account the specific context of postgraduate medical training in Germany [4]. To date, however, there is no orientational framework in German-speaking countries for medical education competencies in postgraduate medical training in the sense of a qualification profile for postgraduate medical educators. The term “postgraduate medical educator” refers to physicians authorised to provide postgraduate training (authorised by the state medical associations) and designated training supervisors (designated by the physicians authorised to provide postgraduate training).
1.1. Orientation of postgraduate medical training towards patient care and the healthcare sector requirements
Both medical doctors in postgraduate training and postgraduate medical educators work within a postgraduate medical training setting that takes place with the competing demands of patient care, teaching and, in the university context, research as well. Because people must be treated by the doctors at the same time, the mandate to provide care regularly conflicts with the mandate to provide postgraduate training. This is particularly evident in the outpatient sector, where patient appointments are tightly scheduled and time restricted. Additionally, other professions must be involved as part of interprofessional care, and the procedural sequences and standards in the various medical disciplines must be integrated. Furthermore, postgraduate medical training is not yet recognised as an independently funded service within the German healthcare system, meaning that provision of the necessary time and human resources is inadequate [5]. Another aspect that should not be overlooked is the balancing of family, private and professional life since this also impacts the framework conditions at postgraduate training sites. Overall, the role of physicians, and consequently the demands placed on the profession, has changed significantly in recent years [6]. Postgraduate medical educators must therefore be able to develop structured curricula for postgraduate medical training and select suitable clinical learning situations, taking into account that it is often not possible to plan for suitable patients. They must also impart knowledge and skills, assess competency development in a workplace-based setting and provide trainees with structured feedback to support their further development [7], [8], [9], [10]. However, there is usually a lack of the teaching formats known from undergraduate education, such as practical exercises, interprofessional and interdisciplinary scenarios, and a training infrastructure consisting of models, simulators or simulation persons. This particularly applies to examination situations at the workplace across both non-procedural and procedural medical specialties [11]. Where necessary, coordination with other locations must take place within the framework of a collaborative medical training network, and evaluation and quality assurance in postgraduate medical training must be driven forward [3].
The availability and further development of artificial intelligence (AI) and large language models (LLM) are additional aspects relevant to healthcare provision and consequently to postgraduate medical training concerns because physicians must understand their opportunities and risks [12]. Evidence shows that the upcoming medical doctors in postgraduate training have already used AI during their medical studies and equally become aware of, but often underestimate, its risks [13]. The current generation of postgraduate medical educators, on the other hand, still needs to develop AI competencies. Against this backdrop, the German Medical Association published a statement [14] that comprehensively assesses AI in the healthcare sector. In the field of medical education and postgraduate medical training [15], [16], [17], additional applications have been published on AI in curricular development, learning support, simulated environments and examination assessments [18].
In summary, these myriad requirements and activities demand that postgraduate medical educators possess specific competencies in order to meet the challenges of postgraduate medical training in the future.
1.2. Competency-based orientation
Educational processes in the healthcare sector are increasingly moving towards a competency-based approach [19]. In international debates as well as in German-speaking countries, the view is increasingly gaining ground that postgraduate medical training should focus primarily on enabling physicians to effectively master profession-specific challenges and preparing them for core medical tasks [20], rather than on the number of hours spent in training or the number of cases treated. Accordingly, Canada’s Royal College of Physicians and Surgeons (CanMEDS) developed a competency model for the context of postgraduate training and continuing professional development [21]. Among other purposes, this competency model is used to develop, e.g., the learning objectives and medical competency roles set out in the National Competency-Based Catalogue of Learning Objectives in Medicine (NKLM) [https://www.nklm.de]) of the medical faculties as well as the German catalogue of topics covered by the written exams [Gegenstandskatalog] issued by the German Institute for Medical and Pharmaceutical Examination Questions (IMPP) [22]. The entrustable professional activities (EPA) described in the NKLM graduate profile and the German catalogue of medical exam topics can help bridge the gap between undergraduate and postgraduate medical training. The EPAs focus on the incremental entrustment of specific, subject-related medical activities to trainees towards the end of their studies, with a view to ensuring readiness for work and professional practice, culminating in the assumption of full responsibility at the end of their postgraduate medical training. This operationalises the learning objectives and competencies required for medical practice [23]. For teaching in undergraduate medical training, Peters et al. had identified specific EPAs: their approaches can also be applied to postgraduate medical training. Above all, the workplace-based teaching activities for postgraduate medical training they discuss are particularly relevant here [24].
1.3. Objective
Given the debate on competency-based approaches in undergraduate medical studies and postgraduate medical training, the increased alignment along clinical competencies, and the need for a systematic intermeshing of undergraduate and postgraduate medical training, the committees for personnel and organizational development in teaching (POiL) and postgraduate medical training (WB) of the GMA aim to formulate a practice-oriented competency framework as part of an interdisciplinary and nationally coordinated development process. This competency framework describes fundamental educational competencies relevant to all postgraduate medical educators, regardless of role or function. Drawing on the original publication on core competences of trainers in vocational education [25], the objectives for developing the competency framework have been adapted and supplemented for the postgraduate medical training context. The objective is to use the competency framework to create a pragmatic guide in order to:
- give postgraduate medical educators an orientation on the specific medical education competencies they are expected to possess
- define uniform criteria for assessing the medical education qualifications of postgraduate medical educators in Germany, taking into account the DACH perspective
- align the medical education curricula of postgraduate training and continuing professional development at the individual postgraduate training sites and make them comparable
- formulate recommendations on the planning and delivery of train-the-trainer (TTT) curricula, including the lecturers’ qualification
- provide a foundation for research into the postgraduate training and continuing professional development of postgraduate medical educators
2. Methods
The competency framework presented here, and the recommendations developed for the planning and delivery of TTT curricula, including lecturers’ qualifications, were drawn up through an iterative consensus-building process aimed at achieving the broadest possible acceptance in German-speaking countries. The development, discussion and voting on the competency framework took place during consensus meetings. The following presentation is aligned with the ACCORD guideline (ACcurate COnsensus Reporting Document) to ensure transparency and reproducibility of the process [26], [27]. The guideline was developed for a wide range of possible consensus procedures (e.g. consensus meetings, focus groups or Delphi techniques). In other words, not all the items listed therein are always relevant to every procedure. Accordingly, the points relating to the handling of survey participants were not applied to the procedure described here. The guideline criteria are presented in tabular form in attachment 1 [Att. 1].
2.1. Working group
A team comprising members of the POiL and WB committees of the GMA was responsible for preparing and organising the process and also participated in the consensus-building process at the same time. The interprofessional group included medical educators and physicians with many years of experience and academic expertise in the field of faculty and staff development and postgraduate medical training (see attachment 2 [Att. 2]). The authors prepared this consensus paper without monetary compensation.
2.2. Existing resources for the development of the competency framework
On 23 March 2024, an initial joint consensus-building meeting compiled the content proposals and relevant sources on the topic. Based on the POiL committee’s position paper on the core competencies for medical educators [25], which served as the main foundation for this publication, an initial draft of a tabular overview was created that set out the six core competency fields adapted to postgraduate medical training, the associated subcompetencies, learning objectives and practical application examples for the postgraduate training sites. Additional sources relied upon included the checklist titled “Train-the-Trainer seminars for physicians authorised to provide postgraduate training” published by the German Society for General Practice and Family Medicine (DEGAM) [28] and the framework recommendations issued by the German Medical Association [2]. These were compared with the consensus paper of the MedizinDidaktikNetz (MDN) [29] and then systematically consolidated into a competency framework for postgraduate medical educators (see attachment 3 [Att. 3]).
In developing the competency framework, the DEGAM’s “postgraduate medical training competency matrix” was also taken into account, along with the four roles that doctors in outpatient postgraduate training can assume within the context of outpatient postgraduate medical training: postgraduate medical educators in clinical practice, lecturers, mentors and examiners [30]. The learning objectives and subcompetencies of the framework presented here were compared with the DEGAM framework; in each case, the discussion focused whether they are also relevant for all other medical disciplines besides general medicine.
2.3. Specific steps in the development process
The individual meetings were structured around tasks assigned in advance and pre-defined milestones. Characterized by open discussions, all participants were on equal footing without any dedicated moderator. Accordingly, changes to the competency fields, subcompetencies and learning objectives were discussed and agreed upon by consensus. No weighting or scoring was applied because all topical areas were assumed to be fundamentally equal. The application and implementation examples were suggested informally by the group. This was because such examples depend on the individual situations at the postgraduate training sites and in the postgraduate medical training courses and therefore should remain flexible. All proposed amendments were accepted or rejected by a simple majority vote of the group. Nine meetings were held to support an iterative discussion process. The development process is presented in attachment 4 [Att. 4].
2.4. Discussion of content
As part of the process, the working group developed guidelines for postgraduate medical educators, together with recommendations for the planning and delivery of TTT curricula and for the qualifications required of course leaders and teaching faculty. Other aspects that generated controversial debate included, e.g. training course duration, supplementary team-building activities (dinners, mentoring), course content relating to the structures of postgraduate medical training and legislation governing the chambers of the healthcare professions, review of competencies, outcome measurement, evaluation of postgraduate training sites with possible sanctions, funding and implementation strategies, etc. Numerous topics were not included in the recommendations so as not to distract the work's focus and/or because they did not fall within the competency domain of the two GMA committees. Our recommendations were discussed, in particular as compared to the DEGAM checklist [28] and the German Medical Association’s framework recommendations on continuing professional development measures for those physician authorised to provide postgraduate training [2] and were further developed in a cross-disciplinary manner.
3. Results
The structure of this competency framework is oriented along six core competency fields for postgraduate medical educators. Based on the model by Görlitz et al. [25], subcompetencies and learning objectives relevant to these six core competency fields were defined for the postgraduate medical training context. Beyond this, we listed application examples for concrete implementation at postgraduate training sites as well as examples of how the learning objectives can be implemented in TTT courses.
The six core competency fields including subcompetencies are as follows:
- Educational practice in medicine: Competent postgraduate medical educators select appropriate learning objectives and design teaching and learning processes that are didactically and methodologically conducive to learning. They assess and monitor doctors in postgraduate training’ learning progress in terms of knowledge, skills and attitudes in an appropriate manner. They also assign tasks to the doctors in postgraduate training in line with their prior knowledge and skills.
- Learner-centred approach: Competent postgraduate medical educators create an atmosphere and environment conducive to learning. They support the individual learning process of doctors in postgraduate training in line with their individual abilities and needs, while building on their prior knowledge.
- Social and communication skills: Competent postgraduate medical educators communicate in a manner appropriate to the target audience, tailored to the situation and results-oriented; they foster a working environment conducive to learning and cooperation. Beyond this, they apply the didactic and methodological aspects of teaching and learning processes in a communicative manner.
- Role modelling and professionalism: Competent postgraduate medical educators ensure that their own professional conduct is consistent with their teaching and learning objectives. They convey the necessity to reflect on their own attitudes and behaviour in light of professional requirements and expectations and demonstrate a willingness to engage in critical self-reflection and lifelong learning.
- Reflection and advancement of personal teaching practice: Competent postgraduate medical educators reflect on their personal teaching practice and continuously develop it.
- Systems-related teaching and learning: Competent postgraduate medical educators utilise or create institutional conditions that promote teaching and learning while complying with the legal requirements governing postgraduate medical training. Such educators consider the structures and processes at their postgraduate training sites, participate in development processes within self-government, and incorporate social and political trends when planning their postgraduate training curricula.
The entire competency framework is presented in attachment 3 [Att. 3]. Table 1 [Tab. 1] presents an extract from the “educational practice in medicine” competency field as one example. This demonstrates how the subcompetency “design teaching and learning processes to be didactically and methodologically learning-conducive” is operationalised in learning objectives.
Table 1: Extract from the “educational practice in medicine” competency field with the subcompetencies “learning objectives and application examples for postgraduate training sites” and TTT courses
Additionally, application and implementation examples of this subcompetency are presented. Application examples refer to concrete situations at postgraduate training sites and include “design clinical teach-learn situations, such as workplace-based knowledge transfer during physician rounds, procedures, surgical interventions, clinical skills training courses, etc.”. Implementation examples refer to the delivery of TTT courses: The techniques or principles to be learned by the postgraduate medical educators are taught or applied in the course in such a way that participants can experience them for themselves from the learners’ perspective and subsequently put them into practice at their own postgraduate training sites. One example is “training methods for structured patient presentations and teaching clinical skills such as the one-minute preceptor, […], Peyton, etc.”.
Table 2 [Tab. 2] presents an overview of the consensus-based recommendations for TTT course planning and delivery along with the faculty qualification requirements.
Table 2: Recommendations for the planning and delivery of TTT curricula for postgraduate medical educators and lecturers’ qualification
4. Discussion
Amongst other aspects, this position paper was intentionally based on the competency model developed by Görlitz et al. [25], which describes the core competencies in medical education required for teachers in higher education. The aim of the consensus process was to systematically transfer the content of the Görlitz model to the context of postgraduate medical training and adapt it to the specific requirements of physicians authorised to provide postgraduate training and designated training supervisors. Specific curricula for educational training alongside concrete application examples for delivery of the courses at postgraduate training sites were formulated for the six core competency fields.
The WFME standards provide an international framework for improving postgraduate medical training [3], [7]. A position paper issued by the GMA Committee on postgraduate medical training identified 90 of the 250 standards listed in the 2015 WFME version as meaningful and controllable for postgraduate medical training in Germany [4]. Our competency framework drew upon many of these WFME learning objectives and refined them for operationalisation in Germany.
Although the 2024 resolution of the German Medical Assembly (Deutscher Ärztetag) [1] mandated the development of a competency framework, only a few medical association jurisdictions offer mandatory medical education courses. It can be assumed that all medical associations are now designing such programmes. In addition to this, the German Medical Association in 2025 adopted framework recommendations for a continuing professional development measure for postgraduate medical educators [2]. These specify a scope of 8-16 work units (equivalent to 45 minutes) and optional thematic modules for continuing professional development measures, which also comprise legal and organisational aspects of postgraduate medical training. Our recommendations for the planning and delivery of TTT curricula for postgraduate medical educators also envisage a minimum of 8-16 work units for a qualification in medical education. In addition, at least four work units are recommended for online preparation to maximize the effectiveness of the face-to-face time. Topics intentionally omitted here include the teaching of formal legal aspects, such as the laws governing the state chambers of healthcare professions, the rights and obligations of postgraduate medical educators, postgraduate training regulations or implementation of the e-logbook. We recommend offering this content during additional time periods and in separate formats. In our view, 8-16 work units on the fundamentals of medical education represent the minimum number needed to sensitise postgraduate medical educators to competency-based approaches to postgraduate medical training and to provide initial training in the medical educational competencies required for this purpose. At many medical schools, mandatory continuing professional development periods for teaching staff are significantly longer, e.g. early in a teacher’s career or as part of a postdoctoral degree. Other medical professions also prepare their practical educators much more thoroughly for their teaching roles in undergraduate training [https://www.gesetze-im-internet.de/pflaprv/__4.html], [https://www.gesetze-im-internet.de/notsan-aprv/BJNR428000013.html]. Accordingly, the authors recommend advanced continuing professional development courses in the form of follow-up meetings focused on key aspects of educational practice in medicine and to foster informal exchange among colleagues. This must be taken into account when developing TTT courses. In general, the medical education courses offered by the faculties are conceptually developed and accredited in accordance with the MedizinDidaktikNetz’s nationally standardised guidelines. These courses can be used to advance and supplement knowledge and, thereby, any previously conferred medical education certificates can be recognised [29], [31]]. Irrespective thereof, we recommend that all postgraduate medical educators take part in the TTT curricula. Our competency framework includes and expands on the German Medical Association’s 2022 framework recommendations [2], while providing specific implementation recommendations on the delivery of TTT courses. We also formulated requirements for the qualifications of faculty members who deliver the courses. Against the backdrop of the German Medical Assembly’s resolution [1], these recommendations, together with the teaching competencies set out in the competency framework, equip TTT seminar providers, such as the state medical associations, with practical criteria and standards for the development of new or the revision of existing TTT curricula.
In Germany, the question is often raised as to whether it is reasonable to expect postgraduate medical educators to have the corresponding qualification in specialised didactics. Some reasons for this are the critical staff shortages that exist at many postgraduate training sites, with a priority given to patients, and the increasing intensity and specialisation of medical practice in both inpatient and outpatient settings. Insufficient funding for postgraduate medical training is also problematic, as the existing remuneration system does not recognise postgraduate medical training as a separate service, but primarily cross-subsidises it through revenues from patient care, thereby impacting the adequate provision of the staff and time resources necessary [5]. The didactic strategies and application examples within our framework address these challenges by including concrete examples of competency-oriented postgraduate medical training, e.g. structured patient presentations, teaching practical clinical skills or the implementation of EPA with workplace-based reviews. They can be easily integrated into the working context at postgraduate training sites and do not place an additional burden on or increase the bureaucracy of the medical training. Another aspect we considered was the transformation of healthcare delivery and the healthcare system through AI and LLMs, as well as its impact on postgraduate medical training.
One strength of our recommendations lies in the fact that they provide a foundation for presenting the courses objectively, in line with our objectives. Only in this way is it possible to evaluate and research the impacts and thereby improve the quality of postgraduate medical training. Beyond this, our recommendations can be used in the development of the postgraduate medical training curricula required by the state medical associations when applying for authorisation. To date, such curricula have been submitted to meet the formal requirements for authorisation but are rarely assessed in terms of their educational feasibility in practical settings. In the future, this could be addressed in terms of quality assurance alongside an evaluation of the postgraduate medical training, the postgraduate training sites and the postgraduate medical educators themselves.
4.1. Postgraduate medical training in Austria and Switzerland
The competency framework was developed with a focus on the postgraduate medical training situation in Germany. To assess the postgraduate medical training situations in Switzerland and Austria, we asked experts with insights into postgraduate medical training in both countries for their assessments:
Competency-based postgraduate medical training is more advanced in Switzerland than in Germany. Since 2022, initial experience with the transition to competency-based medical education has been gathered as part of a Swiss national reform movement [32], [33]. The responsible Swiss Institute of Medical Education (SIME) regards the cultural transformation in teaching as a key building block of the reform. It has become apparent that a shift in focus from the number of hours completed and procedures performed to competencies places greater demands on the teaching skills of postgraduate medical educators. Therefore, it is planned to appoint at least one person with expertise in medical education at each postgraduate training site to serve as a role model, adviser and multiplier for good teaching practices. A Swiss Institute of Medical Education working group has defined the competencies required of such a person and how the courses for teaching these competencies should be structured. Furthermore, criteria for awarding a quality certificate for medical education courses and criteria describing the competencies required of the sought-after person were developed on the basis of data from all medical education courses in Switzerland, whilst also taking international frameworks into account [34], [35]. The process of creating the course database has been described in a reproducible way [36], [37].
In Austria, postgraduate medical training is subject to the Austrian Medical Training Act (ÄAO 2015) [https://www.ris.bka.gv.at/GeltendeFassung.wxe?Abfrage=Bundesnormen&Gesetzesnummer=20009186] by training supervisors and specialist physicians who provide postgraduate training. The didactic preparation of training supervisors and specialist physicians who provide postgraduate medical training is more advanced in Austria than in Germany. This is facilitated by the fact that responsibility for legislating specialist medical training lies with the Austrian federal government, rather than with the states as in Germany. Accordingly, responsibility for implementing the training legislation lies with the Austrian Medical Chamber. In 2024, new guidelines on standards and quality in medical training were published, which adopted the WFME standards for specialist medical training from the 2023 version [7]. The central approach to the qualification of training supervisors and specialist physicians who provide postgraduate medical training is that specialist medical training is not a by-product of medical practice but is conducted in a structured and evidence-based manner. The levels of recommendation are E1 (must), E2 (should) and E3 (can). Accordingly, the responsible parties should devote 20% of their working hours to the relevant training programme, obtain teaching qualifications and be adequately remunerated for their training activities ([38], sections 3.1.4.1-4]), [39]. The long version of the guideline also describes the legal basis under the Austrian Medical Training Act (ÄAO 2015). The Austrian Medical Chamber offers a training programme entitled ‘Training competency for routine clinical practice’ comprising six modules [40]. In these modules, training supervisors and specialist physicians who provide postgraduate medical training acquire evidence-based medical education competency in routine clinical practice and obtain certification for this from the Austrian Medical Chamber. No data are currently available on the practical impact of the new guideline.
4.2. Strengths and weaknesses
Following the ACCORD guideline, all aspects relevant to the consensus-building approach used in this study were addressed when reporting the methodology in order to ensure a high degree of transparency and a reproducible presentation of the process. Although the results were agreed by consensus within an intentionally constituted interdisciplinary group of experts, none of the other stakeholders active in postgraduate medical training verified or ratified the results prior to publication. Hence, the fact that our working group drew solely on its own expertise is an important limitation. No claim is made to completeness. The proposed competency framework forms an important foundation for the further development and redesign of postgraduate medical training whilst serving to enhance the educational qualification of postgraduate medical educators.
5. Conclusions
Our competency framework is designed for practical application and, for the first time, operationalises medical education competencies for postgraduate medical educators in German-speaking countries. Accordingly, there is a need to systematically evaluate and empirically research its implementation at postgraduate training sites, but also the structure and delivery of educational training by the various state medical associations.
Notes
Adoption
The position paper was submitted to the GMA Executive Board which adopted it on 14 September 2026.
Funding
We would like to thank the GMA for its financial support of the committee’s work and for covering the publication costs.
Author contributions
The authors Bernhard Steinweg and Ulrike Sonntag have contributed equally to this publication. All authors were significantly involved in the process.
Authors’ ORCIDs
- Bernhard Steinweg: [0009-0002-0753-7479]
- Ulrike Sonntag: [0000-0001-9576-2734]
- Friederike Bennett: [0009-0001-7059-5332]
- Folkert Fehr: [0000-0001-8495-4167]
- Eckhart G. Hahn: [0000-0003-3261-0105]
- Thomas Kollewe: [0000-0002-0471-6554]
- Raphael Kunisch: [0000-0002-0758-5721]
- Eva K. Hennel: [0000-0002-7625-5785]
Competing interests
The authors declare that they have no competing interests.
References
[1] Bennett F, Neumann-Grutzeck C, Johanning, Kai Herrmann H, Chaoui K, Veelken J, Schaad L, Marschner M, Jurastow I, Landgraf I, vn der Heydt S, Weimann J, Thiede K, Albrecht M, Weiß C, Messer C, Lütje K, Teipel H, Grebe I, Held R, Reichardt J. Beschluss des 128. Deutschen Bundesärztetages, Top IIIc-20. In: Bundesärztekammer Deutschland, editor. Beschlussprotokoll des 128 Deutschen Ärztetages. Mainz: Bundesärztekammer Deutschland; 2024. Zugänglich unter/available from: https://128daet.baek.de/data/media/BIIIc20.pdf[2] Bundesärztekammer. Rahmenempfehlungen für eine Fortbildungsmaßnahme für Weiterbildungsbefugte. Berlin: Bundesärztekammer; 2025. Zugänglich unter/available from: https://www.bundesaerztekammer.de/fileadmin/user_upload/BAEK/Themen/Aus-Fort-Weiterbildung/Fortbildung/20250313_VS_Rahmenempfehlungen_Fortbildungsmassnahme_WBB.pdf
[3] World Federation for Medical Education (WFME). Postgraduate Medical Education: WFME Global Standards For Quality Improvement - The 2015 Revision. London: WFME; 2015. Zugänglich unter/available from: https://wfme.org/standards/pgme/
[4] Schwill S, Kadmon M, Hahn EG, Kunisch R, Berberat PO, Fehr F, Hennel E. The WFME global standards for quality improvement of postgraduate medical education: Which standards are also applicable in Germany? Recommendations for physicians with a license for postgraduate training and training agents. GMS J Med Educ. 2022;39(4):Doc42. DOI: 10.3205/zma001563
[5] Donner-Banzhoff N, Gerlach FM. Ein Vorschlag zur Förderung der ärztlichen Weiterbildung im Kontext einer reformierten Krankenhausfinanzierung. Gesundheitswesen. 2024;86(5):394-397. DOI: 10.1055/a-2189-2209
[6] David DM, Euteneier A, Fischer MR, Hahn EG, Johannink J, Kulike K, Lauch R, Lindhorst E, Noll-Hussong M, Pinilla S, Weih M, WEnnekes V. The future of graduate medical education in Germany - position paper of the Committee on Graduate Medical Education of the Society for Medical Education (GMA). GMS Z Med Ausbild. 2013;30(2):Doc26. DOI: 10.3205/zma000869
[7] World Federation for Medical Education (WFME). WFME Global Standards For Quality Improvement - The 2023 Revision. London: WFME; 2023. Zugänglich unter/available from: https://wfme.org/standards/pgme/
[8] Snell L, Frank JR, Marwan Y. Postgraduate Medical Education - a´Pipeline` to Competence. In: Dent J, Harden R, Hunt D, editors. A Practical Guide For Medical Teachers. 6th ed. London: Elsevier; 2021. p.23-29.
[9] Boursicot K. Performance And Workplace Assessment. In: Dent J, Harden R, Hunt D, editors. A Practical Guide For Medical Teachers. 6th ed. London: Elsevier; 2021. p.289-296.
[10] Cooke M, Irby DM, O'Brien BC. Educating Physicians. A Call for Reform of Medical School and Residency. 1st ed. San Francisco: Jossey-Bass Publishers; 2010.
[11] Cooke M, Irby DM, O'Brien BC. Learning the Physician's Work. In: Cooke M, O'Brien BC, Irby DM, editors. Educating Physicians A Call for Reform of Medical School and Residency. 1st ed. San Francisco: Jossey-Bass Publishers; 2010. p.143 ff.
[12] Omiye JA, Gui H, Rezaei SJ, Zou J, Daneshjou R. Large Language Models in Medicine: The Potentials and Pitfalls. Ann Intern Med. 2024;177(2):210-220. DOI: 10.7326/M23-2772
[13] Moritz S, Romeike B, Stosch C, Tolks D. Generative AI (gAI) in medical education: Chat-GPT and co. GMS J Med Educ. 2023;40(4):Doc54. DOI: 10.3205/zma001636
[14] Bundesärztekammer. Stellungnahme „Künstliche Intelligenz in der Medizin“. Dtsch Ärztebl Online. 21. Februar 2025. Zugänglich unter/available from: https://www.aerzteblatt.de/10.3238/arztebl.2025.Stellungnahme_KI_Medizin
[15] Joseph G, Bhatti N, Mittal R, Bhatti A. Current Application and Future Prospects of Artificial Intelligence in Healthcare and Medical Education: A Review of Literature. Cureus. 2025;17(1):e77313. DOI: 10.7759/cureus.77313
[16] Gordon M, Daniel M, Ajiboye A, Uraiby H, Xu NY, Bartlett R, Hanson J, Haas M, Spadafore M, Grafton-Clarke C, Gasiea RY, Michie C, Corral J, Kwan B, Dolmans D, Thammasitboon S. A scoping review of artificial intelligence in medical education: BEME Guide No. 84. Med Teach. 2024;46(4):446-470. DOI: 10.1080/0142159X.2024.2314198
[17] Verghese BG, Iyer C, Borse T, Cooper S, White J, Sheehy R. Modern artificial intelligence and large language models in graduate medical education: a scoping review of attitudes, applications & practice. BMC Med Educ. 2025;25(1):730. DOI: 10.1186/s12909-025-07321-5
[18] Raji ID, Daneshjou R, Alsentzer E. It’s Time to Bench the Medical Exam Benchmark. New Engl J Med AI. 2025;2(2). DOI: 10.1056/AIe2401235
[19] Ten Cate O. Competency-Based Postgraduate Medical Education: Past, Present and Future. GMS J Med Educ. 2017;34(5):Doc69. DOI: 10.3205/zma001146
[20] Bundesärztekammer. Novellierung der (Muster-) Weiterbildungsordnung. Erfurt: Bundesärztekammer; 2018. Zugänglich unter/available from: www.aerzteblatt.de/2018top8
[21] Frank JR, Snell L, Sherbino J, editors. CanMEDS 2015 Physician Competency Framework Full. 3rd ed. Ottawa: Royal College of Physicians and Surgeons of Canada; 2015. Zugänglich unter/available from: https://canmeds.royalcollege.ca/en/framework
[22] Institut für medizinische und pharmazeutische Prüfungsfragen (IMPP). Gegenstandskataloge für die Ärztliche Prüfung. Mainz: IMPP; 2025. Zugänglich unter/available from: https://www.impp.de/pruefungen/allgemein/gegenstandskataloge.html
[23] Hennus MP, Dagnone JD, Ladenheim RI, Schumacher DJ, Yap M, ten Cate O, Chen HC. Curriculum development for postgraduate training with entrustable professional activities. In: ten Cate O, Burch VC, Chen HC, Chou FC, Hennus MP, editors. Entrustable Professional Activities and Entrustment Decision-Making in Health Professions Education. 1. Aufl. London: Ubiquity Press; 2024. p.157-174. DOI: 10.5334/bdc.n
[24] Peters H, Holzhausen Y, Czeskleba A, Schumann M. Defining a set of teaching EPAs tailored to an undergraduate medical curriculum using a modified Delphi approach. BMC Med Educ. 2024;24(1):588. DOI: 10.1186/s12909-024-05553-5
[25] Görlitz A, Ebert T, Bauer D, Grasl M, Hofer M, Lammerding-Köppel M, Fabry G; GMA Committee on Personal and Organizational Development in Teaching. Core Competencies for Medical Teachers (KLM) - A Position Paper of the GMA Committee on Personal and Organizational Development in Teaching. GMS Z Med Ausbild. 2015;32(2):Doc23. DOI: 10.3205/zma000965
[26] Gattrell WT, Logullo P, van Zuuren EJ, Price A, Hughes EL, Blazey P, Winchester CC, Tovey D, Goldman K, Hungin AP, Harrison N. ACCORD (ACcurate COnsensus Reporting Document): A reporting guideline for consensus methods in biomedicine developed via a modified Delphi. PLoS Med. 2024;21(1):e1004326. DOI: 10.1371/journal.pmed.1004326
[27] Logullo P, van Zuuren EJ, Winchester CC, Tovey D, Gattrell WT, Price A, Harrison N, Goldman K, Chisholm A, Walters K, Blazey P. ACcurate COnsensus Reporting Document (ACCORD) explanation and elaboration: Guidance and examples to support reporting consensus methods. PLoS Med. 2024;21(5):e1004390. DOI: 10.1371/journal.pmed.1004390
[28] Deutsche Gesellschaft für Allgemeinmedizin, Sektion Weiterbildung, AG Train-The Trainer. Checkliste „Train-the-Trainer“- Seminare für Weiterbildungsbefugte (Version 2, 19.12.2019). Berlin: DEGAM; 2019. p.1-4. Zugänglich unter/available from: https://www.degam.de/files/inhalt/sektionen/weiterbildung/2021_Train the Trainer_kurz.pdf
[29] Lammerding-Köppel M. Konsenspapier des bundesweiten MedizinDidaktikNetzes zur gegenseitigen Anerkennung von Leistungen. Tübingen: MedizinDidaktikNetz; 2014. Zugänglich unter/available from: https://medizinische-fakultaeten.de/wp-content/uploads/2022/10/Konsenspapier_r1.pdf
[30] Sonntag U, Bischoff M, Kirchberger J, Roos M, Schwill S, Wild D. Didaktische Kompetenzentwicklung in der Allgemeinmedizin - Was sollten Weiterbildende, Dozierende, Mentor*innen und Prüfende können? ZFA (Stuttgart). 2026;102:191-198. DOI: 10.1007/s44266-026-00522-1
[31] Medizinischer Fakultätentag. Didaktische Qualifizierungsangebote zur Professionalisierung der Hochschullehrenden in der Medizin. Berlin: MFT; 2025. Zugänglich unter/available from: https://medizinische-fakultaeten.de/mdn/
[32] Pinilla S, Bauer W, Breckwoldt J, Burkhart CS, Hennel EK, Marty AP, von Wartburg U, Brodmann Maeder M, Huwendiek S. Introducing entrustable professional activities for postgraduate medical training in Switzerland. GMS J Med Educ. 2024;41(5):Doc60. DOI: 10.3205/zma001715
[33] Schwitz F, Brodmann Maeder M, Hennel EK. Competency-based education - the reform of postgraduate medical training in Switzerland. GMS J Med Educ. 2024;41(5):Doc62. DOI: 10.3205/zma001717
[34] Sidhu NS, Allen KJ, Civil N, Johnstone CSH, Wong M, Taylor JA, Gough K, Hennessy M. Competency domains of educators in medical, nursing, and health sciences education: An integrative review. Med Teach. 2023;45(2):219-228. DOI: 10.1080/0142159X.2022.2126758
[35] Academy of Medical Educators, editor. Professional Standards for medical, dental and veterinary educators. 4th ed.. Cardiff: Academy of Medical Educators; 2022.
[36] Schweizerisches Institut für ärztliche Weiter- und Fortbildung SIWF/ISFM. Swiss Medical Education Course Compass. Bern: SIWF; 2024. Zugänglich unter/available from: https://compass.siwf.ch/Homepage
[37] Gashi A, Brodmann Maeder M, Hennel EK. Making Medical Education Courses Visible: Theory-Based Development of a National Database. JMIR Med Educ. 2025;11:e62838. DOI: 10.2196/62838
[38] Österreichische Ärztekammer. Standard- und Qualitätsleitlinien der Ärzteausbildung. Leitlinie der Österreichischen Ärztekammer. Kurzversion. Wien: Österreichische Ärztekammer; 2024. p.9. Zugänglich unter/available from: https://www.aerztekammer.at/documents/d/content-pool/standard-und-qualitatsleitlinien-der-arzteausbildung-kurzversion
[39] Medwedeff T. Neue Ausbildungs-Leitlinien: Ausbildung besser managen. Osterr Arzteztg. 2025. Zugänglich unter/available from: https://aerztezeitung.at/2025/oaz-artikel/aktuelles-aus-der-oeak/neue-ausbildungs-leitlinien-ausbildung-besser-managen/
[40] Österreichische Ärztekammer und Österreichische Akademie der Ärzte. Ausbildungskompetenz für den klinischen Alltag. Wien: Österreichische Akademie der Ärzte; 2025. Zugänglich unter/available from: https://www.arztakademie.at/ausbildungskompetenz



