The “integrated midwifery science – biochemistry – physiology track” in the BSc midwifery science programme in Hamburg as a model for the interdisciplinary teaching of basic biosciences
Birgit-Christiane Zyriax 1Louisa Kerschke 1,2
Janne Schmittinger 1,2
Lena Haarmann 1
Andreas H. Guse 3,4
Björn-Philipp Diercks 3
Anna Wortmann 3
Sonja Mohr 4
Tobias Heinrich 5
Desirée Loreth 5
Alexander Peter Schwoerer 5
1 University Medical Center Hamburg-Eppendorf, Midwifery Science – Health Services Research and Prevention, Institute for Health Services Research in Dermatology and Nursing, Hamburg, Germany
2 University Medical Center Hamburg-Eppendorf, Midwifery Science – Obstetrics and Prenatal Medicine, Department of Obstetrics and Prenatal Medicine, Hamburg, Germany
3 University Medical Center Hamburg-Eppendorf, Department of Biochemistry and Molecular Cell Biology, Hamburg, Germany
4 University Medical Center Hamburg-Eppendorf, Faculty of Medicine, Dean’s Office for Education, Hamburg, Germany
5 University Medical Center Hamburg-Eppendorf, Institute of Cellular and Integrative Physiology, Hamburg, Germany
Abstract
Objective: A six-week interdisciplinary teaching format was integrated into the first semester of the BSc midwifery science programme in Hamburg.
Developed jointly by the disciplines of midwifery science, biochemistry and physiology, the integrated track (iSTRANG) links basic science subjects with practice-relevant prevention content through a topic-centred approach. It aims to facilitate students’ engagement with scientific and medical subjects and to foster foundational competencies. This paper describes the development process, teaching content and subsequent refinements of the iSTRANG, as well as evaluation and examination results from the first five cohorts.
Methods: The curriculum was developed iteratively by an interdisciplinary steering group, guided by Kern’s curriculum development approach and principles of curricular integration. Each weekly topic is introduced in a midwifery science lecture and complemented by lectures from the other disciplines. Accompanying seminars consolidate students’ knowledge, while each week concludes with an interdisciplinary case discussion focusing on the transfer of theory into practice.
Results: Student satisfaction and examination performance were consistently high.
Based on standardised student evaluations, examination performance and feedback from teaching staff, the curriculum was refined, resulting in increased satisfaction across several aspects. These refinements focused particularly on coordination between disciplines, thematic priorities, the transfer of theory into practice, and students’ heterogeneous prior knowledge.
Conclusion: The iSTRANG concept and its accompanying measures provide a practice-oriented model for interdisciplinary teaching formats designed to integrate basic scientific knowledge into the Midwifery Science curriculum in a way that is relevant to professional practice.
Keywords
midwifery science, prevention, basic sciences, medicine, biochemistry, physiology, interdisciplinary teaching
1. Introduction
Following the reform of the German midwifery act, since 2020 qualification as a midwife in Germany has required completion of a six- to eight-semester practice-integrated degree programme [1], [2], [3]. Based on the 2024 competency framework of the International Confederation of Midwives, students should be educated as reflective, evidence-based practitioners with expertise spanning family planning through to the promotion of long-term health [4]. A conceptual framework for continuity of care is provided by the so-called “continuum of care”, published by Sayn-Wittgenstein in 2007 (see figure 1 [Fig. 1]) [5]. Prevention and health promotion for women and their families are core areas of midwifery practice. Ideally, these practice-integrated, pre-registration degree programmes aim to closely interlink theory and practice from the first semester onwards [1], [6]. The German study and examination regulations for midwives (HebStPrV), together with the disciplines involved in teaching, provide an overarching competency framework [https://www.gesetze-im-internet.de/hebstprv/BJNR003900020.html].
Figure 1: Continuum of care
Professional, high-quality care provided by midwives to women throughout the reproductive phase of life and to their families along the continuum of care (modified from [5]).
A key qualification objective of the transition to academic midwifery education is to enable midwives to integrate scientific foundations with medical, psychosocial and health-promoting aspects on an evidence-based basis and to incorporate these into their practice [7], [8]. At present, however, these competencies have not been specified in detail for Midwifery Science degree programmes, for example in a framework comparable to the German national competency-based catalogue of learning objectives for undergraduate medical education. Structural models and discipline-specific didactic concepts are likewise lacking.
The faculty of medicine in Hamburg has many years of experience with integrated model curricula in medicine and dentistry. This experience indicates that the teaching of complex basic scientific and medical concepts particularly benefits from interdisciplinary, application-oriented teaching approaches, which have also received positive evaluations [9], [10], [11].
Against this background, Hamburg university of applied sciences and the faculty of Medicine at the university of Hamburg have offered Germany’s first cross-institutional, practice-integrated BSc Midwifery Science programme since the winter semester of 2020/21, with 60 students per cohort [6].
The seven-semester curriculum has a modular structure and prepares students to plan and undertake the core activities of midwifery practice on a scientific and evidence-based basis. A central structural principle of the programme is curricular integration, whereby basic scientific and midwifery content is interlinked around common themes. In addition, key content is revisited and explored in greater depth across successive semesters with increasing complexity, following the principles of a spiral curriculum [12]. A key didactic feature is the early transfer of theory into practice, which is systematically fostered from the beginning of the programme. An institutionalised quality management system, based among other measures on student evaluations and examination performance, supports the continuous improvement of structural and content-related aspects of teaching practice and thus serves as a key tool for ongoing curriculum development.
The “integrated midwifery science-biochemistry-physiology track” (iSTRANG – acronym derived from the German integrierter Strang, “integrated strand/track”) was developed for the first-semester module “basic biosciences” and implemented with the first student cohort. Embedded as a longitudinal track within the 14-week module, iSTRANG is designed to provide midwifery science students with a more accessible and practice-oriented introduction to the basic sciences of biochemistry and physiology. It does so by linking relevant aspects of prevention in midwifery practice along the continuum of care (see figure 1 [Fig. 1]) with foundational concepts from these two disciplines across six weekly topics. By teaching complex scientific concepts in an applied context, the aim was to develop a model teaching format that facilitates the early transfer of theory into practice before students undertake their first three-week clinical placement in the first semester. The topics selected for iSTRANG not only provide essential foundations for the further development of competencies but also connect with teaching units in subsequent semesters.
The aim of this report is to systematically describe the development, implementation and continuous refinement of the interdisciplinary iSTRANG teaching format within the BSc midwifery science programme in Hamburg as a model for the interdisciplinary teaching of basic biosciences. It presents the approach adopted by the participating disciplines, the content of the individual module weeks, and key adaptations made on the basis of student evaluations, examination performance and feedback from teaching staff across the first five cohorts. In doing so, the report provides a basis for transferring the model to other institutions.
2. Project description
The iSTRANG within the BSc midwifery science programme was developed by an interdisciplinary steering group comprising the teaching leads for midwifery science, biochemistry and physiology. The iterative development process was guided by Kern’s curriculum development approach [13], with the stages of problem identification, needs assessment, definition of objectives, development and implementation of educational strategies, and evaluation undertaken iteratively. The structure and design were informed by established curricular models and principles of higher education pedagogy for integrated, practice-oriented teaching formats. Decision-making was based on transparent criteria and drew on local experience gained from implementing the integrated model curricula in medicine and dentistry [8], [9], [10], [11].
2.1. Curricular structure
2.1.1. Curricular positioning and rationale for integration
The degree programme is designed as a spiral curriculum in which content is revisited and explored in greater depth across successive semesters [12]. The first semester comprises three overlapping modules (M1-M3), each with a theoretical focus. The 14-week M1 module, “basic biosciences”, provides foundational medical knowledge that is systematically revisited at higher levels of the spiral curriculum in the context of clinical and counselling-related topics. Accordingly, the module includes teaching from a range of disciplines: anaesthesiology, anatomy, biochemistry, obstetrics, midwifery science, microbiology and physiology.
The development of iSTRANG was driven by the curricular objective of linking foundational knowledge with practice-relevant requirements of midwifery at an early stage through close interdisciplinary coordination. iSTRANG was implemented as a six-week block within Module M1 (see figure 2 A [Fig. 2]), integrating the participating disciplines around common themes and linking discipline-specific content through its practical application. Within iSTRANG, 15 teaching hours were allocated to midwifery science, 20 to biochemistry and 14 to physiology, with each teaching hour comprising 45 minutes. Teaching from the other disciplines and on other topics was predominantly scheduled before or after iSTRANG.
Figure 2: Curricular integration
Integration of iSTRANG as a six-week block within the 14-week first-semester M1 module “Basic Biosciences” (A). iSTRANG is embedded within the module according to a fixed weekly structure and is flanked by teaching from other disciplines and on other topics (hatched). This includes additional teaching within Module M1 as well as teaching from Modules M2 and M3 unrelated to M1/iSTRANG. Within the weekly structure (B), lectures were delivered sequentially to the entire cohort, while seminars were conducted on a rotational basis (group size: 20 students). The weekly topic concluded with a team-teaching session on Thursday afternoon. On Mondays, Wednesdays and Fridays, students attended teaching outside iSTRANG in addition to undertaking self-directed study (approximately 8 hours per week).
The curricular structure of iSTRANG is based on level 7 (“correlation”) of Harden’s integration ladder [12]. This approach preserves predetermined teaching allocations and responsibilities within individual disciplines while ensuring close coordination of content, thereby enabling a level of integration that is both feasible within the local context and extensive in scope. In iSTRANG, this is achieved through a common weekly topic that structures the contributions from the individual disciplines and brings them together in an interdisciplinary case discussion.
2.1.2. Educational rationale
The educational design of iSTRANG was primarily informed by principles of andragogy [14] and constructive alignment [15]. Accordingly, the weekly topics were structured around the continuum of care (see figure 1 [Fig. 1]), anchoring the corresponding teaching sessions in typical counselling and prevention scenarios and thereby ensuring their relevance to professional practice. In line with constructive alignment, learning objectives, teaching activities and assessment requirements were aligned with one another. The competencies addressed in iSTRANG are predominantly within the cognitive domain [16] and provide the foundation for the increasing complexity of content in subsequent semesters.
2.1.3. Weekly structure and teaching sequence
To promote sustained competency development, the weekly structure was designed to combine different teaching formats, revisit content at intervals (“spaced repetition”), active retrieval of previously learned material (“active recall”) [17] and systematically apply it to practice-related contexts to facilitate the transfer of theory into practice.
iSTRANG followed a fixed weekly structure, with lectures and seminars held on designated days (see figure 2 B [Fig. 2] and section 3.1.1), while the remaining weekdays were allocated to self-directed learning and teaching in modules M2 and M3, which were thematically independent of iSTRANG. Within this weekly structure, a recurring teaching sequence was used. Each introductory midwifery science lecture established a specific counselling or prevention scenario as the context for application. The subsequent biochemistry and physiology lectures built on this context and taught the underlying basic scientific principles. During the subsequent period of self-directed learning, students reviewed and consolidated this content and prepared for the seminars. The seminars provided opportunities for active engagement with the material through interactive discussions based on the lecture content. Students were explicitly encouraged to raise their own questions and relate the content to their previous professional experiences and observations. Each week concluded with an interdisciplinary case discussion in which content from the different disciplines was integrated and applied to typical practice scenarios. In this way, the transfer of theory into practice was systematically prepared and implemented throughout the entire sequence.
2.2. Selection and prioritisation of teaching content
The weekly topics and interdisciplinary teaching content were determined iteratively by the steering group on the basis of the curricular and educational principles described above. For each week, the disciplines defined complementary content that together formed an integrated whole (see figure 3 A [Fig. 3]). The following priorities guided the selection of teaching content:
- Transfer of theory into practice: Selection of weekly topics along the continuum of care (see figure 1 [Fig. 1]) [5]
- Continuity within the spiral curriculum: Selection of content that provides disciplinary foundations for subsequent modules
- Integration: Use of areas of overlap between disciplines while balancing the available teaching time
- Competency development: Alignment with the fundamental ICM competencies and the competencies defined in the HebStPrV [7]
- Extended scope of practice: For example, in relation to the new S3 guideline “antenatal care in uncomplicated pregnancy”, which is currently under development [18]
- Demographic developments: Consideration of topics of increasing relevance, such as higher maternal age and the growing prevalence of high-risk pregnancies [6]
- Research relevance: Incorporation of research priorities of the faculty of medicine, such as woman-centred health services research [19].
Figure 3: Educational integration model of iSTRANG
Overview of the overarching topic-centred integration model, including discipline-specific thematic blocks and relevant criteria for selecting the weekly topics (A). Example of the implementation of the weekly topic “Body Weight and Physical Activity”, showing specific discipline-related thematic blocks and their relationship to the continuum of care (B).
2.3. Summative assessment
To assess the intended competency development, and in accordance with the principles of constructive alignment, the predominantly cognitive nature of the teaching content, and considerations of feasibility, a final written examination comprising 50 single-best-answer questions with five response options was implemented (midwifery science: 16 questions; biochemistry: 17 questions; physiology: 17 questions) [15], [16]. The remaining module content was assessed in a separate written examination. All examination questions underwent peer review to ensure the quality of their content.
2.4. Student evaluation
Student evaluation of teaching is governed by the “regulations for the evaluation of study programmes and teaching at the faculty of medicine, university of Hamburg”, which specify the purpose, scope and procedures of evaluation as well as the dissemination and publication of results. The evaluation framework includes a summative evaluation at the end of each module. Following each iteration, every module is evaluated using standardised online questionnaires administered via the faculty’s own degree programme management system. Data collection begins immediately after the module examination. All students who attended the module are invited to participate voluntarily in the evaluation and receive a reminder after approximately two weeks. Data collection closes after approximately four weeks. Data are processed in a multi-stage procedure tailored to the respective target groups: members of the curriculum committee receive a complete module report, including anonymised free-text comments, while teaching staff receive individualised reports covering their own teaching sessions.
The questionnaire includes general module items used across all degree programmes within the Faculty to enable comparisons. Students are also asked to rate their satisfaction with each type of teaching session within each discipline. In addition, the curriculum committee may introduce programme-specific items. Alongside satisfaction with iSTRANG and the individual discipline-specific teaching sessions, these items are a particular focus of the present study. For example, the following items were added for quality assurance of iSTRANG: “The content of the weekly topic was well coordinated across the participating disciplines” and “The expert panels/case studies contributed to a better understanding of the weekly topic”.
All items were rated on a six-point Likert scale. A different response format was used to assess perceptions of the demands posed by the course content. Free-text fields complemented the quantitative items. Data were analysed descriptively using means and confidence intervals and inferentially, taking the distribution of the data into account. The non-parametric Mann-Whitney U test was used to evaluate the interventions, and effect sizes were calculated to assess their practical significance [20].
2.5. Iterative development process
A comprehensive quality assurance framework is established for the midwifery science programme at the faculty of medicine. As part of this framework, a curriculum committee comprising representatives of all participating disciplines and students is responsible for coordinating the degree programme across modules. Following each iteration of a module, the dean’s office for education provides the discipline representatives and teaching staff involved with all evaluation and examination results. Taking into account the achievement of the intended learning objectives, teaching staff assessments of the teaching delivered, and the perspectives and interests of students, teaching staff, institute directors and the dean’s office for education, the curriculum committee identified areas for development and formulated corresponding recommendations. Based on these recommendations, the interdisciplinary iSTRANG steering group developed and implemented targeted structural and content-related adaptations. In this way, Kern’s curriculum development cycle was applied continuously as an iterative sequence of evaluation, renewed needs assessment, adaptation and implementation.
3. Results
3.1. Structure and content
The following sections present the structure and content of iSTRANG as currently implemented in the curriculum following its development across the first five cohorts. In accordance with the topic-centred approach to integration described above, iSTRANG is structured around common themes and embedded within the first semester of the degree programme (see figure 2 A [Fig. 2]).
3.1.1. Weekly structure
Each weekly topic is introduced by a midwifery science lecture, followed by lectures from the other disciplines (see figure 2 B [Fig. 2]). The content is consolidated in seminars and, in midwifery science, supplemented by aspects relating to counselling. Each weekly topic concludes with a 45-minute interdisciplinary case discussion delivered through team teaching by teaching staff from all participating disciplines.
3.1.2. Weekly topics
During the development of iSTRANG, six weekly topics of increasing complexity were defined according to the selection criteria described in section 2.2. In keeping with the approach to curricular integration described above, the topics were selected and structured along the continuum of care (see section 2.2). The weekly topics, overarching teaching content of the individual disciplines, and their primary links to the continuum of care [5] are presented in table 1 [Tab. 1]. Figure 3 B [Fig. 3] provides an example of the discipline-specific teaching content for the weekly topic “body weight and physical activity”, with a more detailed breakdown provided in table 2 [Tab. 2]. As coordination of teaching content across the participating disciplines is fundamental to integrated teaching approaches, the content was reviewed and coordinated repeatedly over the reporting period.
Table 1: Weekly topics, disciplinary contributions and relationship to the continuum of care 
Table 2: Example of discipline-specific teaching content for the weekly topic “body weight and physical activity”
3.1.3. Interdisciplinary case discussions
At the end of each weekly topic, students work through a typical case from counselling practice in an interdisciplinary case discussion facilitated by teaching staff from the participating disciplines (see table 3 [Tab. 3] for an example). The tasks are designed to promote the transfer of knowledge to specific counselling situations. Following small-group work, students discuss the tasks in plenary. This structured case-based approach provides an integrative conclusion to each weekly topic, bringing together the intended transfer of theory into practice.
Table 3: Example of the case discussion for the weekly topic “body weight and physical activity”
3.2. Summative assessment
Figure 4 [Fig. 4] summarises the results of the final examination for the 2021 to 2024 cohorts. In 2020, a written assignment was used as the assessment format due to the COVID-19 pandemic. Pass rates for the written examination were very high across all cohorts: one student failed the first attempt in each of 2021/22, 2022/23 and 2023/24, and two students failed the first attempt in 2024/25. On average, students achieved 41.7 out of a maximum of 50 points (standard deviation: 5.6 points). There were no statistically significant differences between cohorts. However, comparison of the proportion of available points achieved in each discipline revealed statistically significant differences between disciplines (see figure 4 [Fig. 4]). Across all cohorts, students achieved higher scores on questions in midwifery science and biochemistry than on those in physiology.
Figure 4: Final examination
Scores achieved by discipline and cohort (expressed as percentages; means and 95% confidence intervals; 2021/22: n=58; 2022/23: n=60; 2023/24: n=58; 2024/25: n=60). Statistically significant results for comparisons between physiology, biochemistry and midwifery sScience: 2021/22: H=10.205, p=0.006, d=0.449; 2022/23: H=32.297, p<0.001, d=0.909; 2023/24: H=23.392, p<0.001, d=0.756; 2024/25: H=25.433, p<0.001, d=0.781.
3.3. Evaluation results and further development
A total of 180 completed questionnaires were available from the student evaluations of the first five cohorts (2020/21: n=52, response rate 80%; 2021/22: n=35, response rate 56%; 2022/23: n=29, response rate 46%; 2023/24: n=33, response rate 52%; 2024/25: n=31, response rate 48%). From the outset, the results indicated very high levels of satisfaction with iSTRANG and with the coordination between disciplines (see figure 5 [Fig. 5]). By contrast, the contribution of the expert panels/case studies to a better understanding of the weekly topic was initially rated comparatively less favourably (see figure 5 [Fig. 5]). In the free-text comments, students particularly valued the overall concept, the sequence of lectures, seminars and case discussions, the weekly topics, the different disciplinary perspectives, and the way in which the disciplines were interconnected to promote the integration of basic sciences with practical application (see table 4 [Tab. 4]). Together with feedback from teaching staff, the evaluation findings formed a key basis for the iterative development process and prompted the three major adaptations described below.
Figure 5: Student evaluation of teaching
Agreement with items assessing satisfaction, coordination of content and the contribution of team teaching over time (means and 95% confidence intervals; 2020/21: n=52; 2021/22: n=35; 2022/23: n=29; 2023/24: n=33; 2024/25: n=31). The arrow indicates the revision of the weekly topics and the team-teaching session. Statistically significant results for comparisons of agreement ratings before and after the revision: coordination of content: U=91768.5, Z=7.217, p<0.001, r=0.26; contribution of team teaching: U=15940, Z=4.548, p<0.001, r=0.22.
Table 4: Examples of comments from student evaluations that informed further development
3.3.1. Weekly topics
In the initial years, students rated the coordination of content between the participating disciplines comparatively less favourably (see figure 5 [Fig. 5]). Recurrent inconsistencies in the alignment of content with the respective weekly topic were also identified (see table 4 [Tab. 4]). For the winter semester of 2023/24, the steering group therefore undertook a comprehensive revision focusing on the detailed allocation of content across disciplines and its alignment with the weekly topics. Based on suggestions made in students’ free-text comments, additional content was also incorporated into the weekly topics. For example, “stigmatisation and discrimination by healthcare professionals” was added to the weekly topic “body weight and physical activity”. Following these changes, satisfaction with interdisciplinary coordination increased significantly (see figure 5 [Fig. 5]). This highlights the importance of consistent coordination across disciplines within the chosen integration strategy.
3.3.2. Transfer of theory into practice in the case discussions
During the first three years, the interdisciplinary sessions held at the end of each week and involving representatives of all three disciplines were used primarily to review content and clarify outstanding questions, including questions spanning multiple disciplines (“expert panels”). During this period, however, students’ ratings of whether the expert panels contributed to a better understanding of the weekly topics were comparatively low (see figure 5 [Fig. 5]). Based on feedback from students and teaching staff, from the winter semester of 2023/24 onwards the concluding team-teaching session was redesigned to focus on knowledge transfer through structured case studies involving practice-relevant counselling tasks (see table 3 [Tab. 3]). This provided a more consistent operationalisation of the transfer of theory into practice envisaged in the original concept. The adaptation was reflected in a statistically significant improvement in students’ ratings of the contribution of these sessions to their understanding of the weekly topics (see figure 5 [Fig. 5]).
3.3.3. Differences in ratings between disciplines and strengthening prior knowledge through cash courses
Within individual disciplines, student evaluations showed similar ratings for lectures and seminars, although ratings differed between disciplines (see figure 6 A and B [Fig. 6]). Free-text comments suggested potential reasons for these differences, including a lack of a clear connection between Biochemistry content and the weekly topic or limited relevance to practice (see table 4 [Tab. 4]). Students’ perceptions of the demands posed by the different disciplines also varied (see figure 7 [Fig. 7]). For example, in the winter semester of 2021/22, almost 90% of students reported feeling “(somewhat) overwhelmed” by the biochemistry content. Free-text comments indicated that the academic level was perceived as too demanding (see table 4 [Tab. 4]). To address gaps in foundational knowledge, extracurricular crash courses comprising one lecture and two seminars were introduced in the winter semester of 2022/23. These voluntary courses are tailored to students’ prior knowledge and review chemistry content at upper-secondary-school level [21]. They were attended by a high proportion of students and received very positive evaluations (see table 4 [Tab. 4] and table 5 [Tab. 5]). The courses reduced students’ perceived burden. For example, the proportion of students who reported feeling “(somewhat) overwhelmed” by biochemistry fell to approximately 70% in the following winter semester. At the same time, satisfaction with Biochemistry teaching increased significantly (see figure 6 [Fig. 6]). Nevertheless, differences in ratings between disciplines persisted in subsequent cohorts, with students continuing to perceive biochemistry as more demanding than the other disciplines (see figure 7 [Fig. 7]).
Figure 6: Student satisfaction with lectures (A) and seminars (B)
Agreement with the respective items over time (means and 95% confidence intervals; 2020/21: n=52; 2021/22: n=35; 2022/23: n=29; 2023/24: n=33; 2024/25: n=31). The arrows indicate the introduction of the crash courses. Statistically significant results for comparisons of agreement ratings before and after the introduction of the crash courses: Biochemistry lectures: U=5536.5, Z=4.637, p<0.001, r=0.35; Midwifery Science seminars: U=4805.5, Z=2.487, p=0.013, r=0.19; Biochemistry seminars: U=5234, Z=3.714, p<0.001, r=0.28; Physiology seminars: U=3510, Z=-2.002, p=0.045, r=0.15.
Figure 7: Students’ perceptions of the demands posed by the individual disciplines
Students’ self-reported perceptions of the demands posed by the respective disciplines over time. 2020/21: n=52; 2021/22: n=35; 2022/23: n=29; 2024/25: n=31. No data are available for 2023/24.
Table 5: Student evaluation of the crash course
4. Discussion
With the launch of the BSc midwifery science programme in the winter semester of 2020/21, iSTRANG was integrated into the first semester as a six-week longitudinal, topic-centred curriculum. Developed through interdisciplinary collaboration, the teaching format aims to integrate basic science subjects with applied prevention content relevant to core midwifery practice, thereby fostering a foundational, scientifically informed understanding and approach to practice. The chosen curricular integration strategy preserves the distinct identity of each discipline while systematically establishing links between their content around practice-relevant topics. Feedback from students across the first five cohorts, covering aspects ranging from the format itself and interdisciplinary integration to the transfer of theory into practice, indicated very high levels of satisfaction from the outset with the overall concept, the structured sequence of lectures, seminars and case discussions, the links between disciplines, and the relevance to practice. The institutionalised quality assurance system, based primarily on student evaluations and the perspectives of teaching staff, enabled the format to evolve continuously through ongoing adaptations and targeted improvements. The increase in student satisfaction demonstrates the importance of quality assurance measures in supporting curricular innovation.
4.1. Coordination and implementation
Coordination between the participating disciplines was central to the iterative implementation of iSTRANG. Its structure and content were continuously reviewed and adapted over the first cohorts. During the initial development phase, the structure and content of iSTRANG were selected by the steering group with reference to the continuum of care, international publications and the competency framework of the International Confederation of Midwives [4], and were developed collaboratively across the disciplines. Particularly important to its sustained development were weekly discussions among teaching staff about the structure, educational approach and content of each week following the case discussions, direct interaction with students, systematic student evaluations, examination performance, meetings of the Curriculum Committee and the annual teaching conference.
From the outset, the final examination results indicated that the intended cognitive learning outcomes, including integrative aspects and their application to professional practice, had been achieved. Together with the highly positive evaluation results, these findings indicated no need for changes to the fundamental structural, educational and thematic concepts underlying iSTRANG. Instead, adaptations focused primarily on refining the coordination of content between disciplines, adjusting specific thematic priorities, implementing the transfer of theory into practice, and addressing differences in students’ prior knowledge, particularly in biochemistry. The adaptations described above, together with the examination and evaluation results, support the viability of the chosen integration strategy within its curricular context and underscore the importance of systematic, theory-informed development as part of an iterative curriculum development process.
4.2. Selection of weekly topics
The topics were initially selected primarily from the perspective of teaching staff through close and regular coordination between the disciplines. The selection process considered criteria such as demographic developments, educational considerations, relevance to practice, available teaching time and continuity within the spiral curriculum. A key consideration was to select topics that both had a clear connection to the continuum of care and provided opportunities for interdisciplinary links between midwifery science, biochemistry and physiology. Given the teaching staff’s positive experience with the previously developed medicine and dentistry programmes, and the absence to date of a comparable concept in midwifery science programmes, the initial selection of topics was undertaken on the premise that they would be continuously adapted through an institutionalised process rather than through a time-consuming Delphi process. Implementation across the first cohorts confirmed a high level of acceptance of the weekly topics, while specific areas of emphasis were further developed over the first five years. The selected weekly topics provided valuable foundational knowledge and established links with teaching units in subsequent semesters. For example, content from the week on “cardiovascular and metabolic women’s health”, including pre-eclampsia and gestational diabetes, is revisited in the fifth semester. External validation of the content against a national catalogue of learning objectives would be desirable but is not currently feasible in the absence of a nationwide consensus. Student evaluations indicated a high overall level of acceptance of the weekly topics from the first cohort onwards. Subsequently, student feedback provided through module reports, including anonymised free-text comments, as well as feedback given directly to the discipline leads, formed an important basis for determining thematic priorities over the first five years. For example, this feedback led to the incorporation of respectful and sensitive communication in relation to obesity (see table 4 [Tab. 4]) and to further improvements in the coordination of weekly topics across the participating disciplines (see figure 5 [Fig. 5]).
4.3. Transfer of theory into practice
To strengthen the transfer of theory into practice, each weekly topic was introduced in the midwifery science lecture, explored in greater depth through recurring references in the subsequent lectures and seminars, and concluded with an integrative session. Qualitative and quantitative student feedback provided in the module reports was the principal basis for assessing the effectiveness of this transfer. Interestingly, the initial expert-panel format, which had been used with considerable success in the faculty’s integrated medical degree programme, proved less suitable as a concluding weekly format in the midwifery science programme. Possible contributing factors included insufficient structure in the initial format, limited practical application, particularly in the context of a practice-integrated degree programme, and perceived overlap with the preceding seminars. The expert panels were therefore replaced by structured, interdisciplinary case discussions. This format specifically promotes the transfer of knowledge to practice-relevant counselling tasks, thereby strengthening the application of foundational knowledge to professional decision-making situations. In the student evaluations, the case discussions were rated more favourably than the original expert panels in terms of their relevance to practice (see table 4 [Tab. 4] and figure 5 [Fig. 5]). This difference in acceptance highlights the need to tailor integrated teaching formats to the development of profession-specific identity. Compared with medical students at a similar stage of their studies, students in a pre-registration midwifery science programme have a stronger orientation towards professional practice. The transition from a primarily discursive panel format to structured, case-based teaching is therefore also consistent with principles of andragogy in health professions education, according to which relevance and proximity to practice are direct predictors of learning success [14].
4.4. Introduction of crash courses
When iSTRANG was designed, the aim was to achieve a comparable quantitative and qualitative workload across the disciplines. Based on student evaluations (see figure 7 [Fig. 7]) and individual feedback provided to teaching staff during teaching sessions, differences in students’ perceived workload between disciplines were continuously addressed by adapting, rescheduling and reducing content. In particular, targeted support through crash courses reduced students’ perceived burden. Nevertheless, student evaluations continued to indicate an above-average perceived burden associated with biochemistry (see figure 7 [Fig. 7]). Possible reasons include discipline-specific differences in scientific complexity, content and/or orientation towards professional practice. Sociodemographic factors such as previous degrees, professional experience in healthcare, or the length of time since leaving school may also have an influence [22], [23]. Based on experience within the faculty, the crash courses will be further developed to better address students’ heterogeneous needs [24]. Interestingly, students’ perceived burden associated with the content of the individual disciplines did not correspond to their final examination results, in which they consistently achieved higher scores in midwifery science and biochemistry than in physiology. Nor was the introduction of the crash courses associated with any demonstrable effect on Biochemistry examination performance. This suggests that discipline-specific differences in subject matter may be a key determinant of perceived burden and that perceived burden is not predictive of examination performance. From the perspective of cognitive load theory, the high perceived complexity of Biochemistry represents a particularly high intrinsic cognitive load for students. The crash courses reduced this load by providing structured preparatory support, thereby freeing cognitive capacity for more advanced learning processes [25], [26], although they did not directly reduce students’ subjective perception of burden during the semester. These findings are therefore consistent with compensatory learning activities on the part of students.
4.5. Challenges, limitations and further development
The topic-centred, interdisciplinary approach presents a challenge for students, partly because it is often addressed only to a limited extent in discipline-centred textbooks. Access to the material can be facilitated through structured teaching resources specifically tailored to the local curriculum. The faculty of medicine in Hamburg has extensive positive experience with this approach through the digital “iMED textbook” used in its integrated medical degree programme [9]. A comparable resource has not yet been developed to the same extent for iSTRANG. Relevant content from the weekly topics has been prepared for a textbook; however, a textbook can reflect the necessary breadth and the dynamic nature of continuous curriculum development only to a limited extent [27].
The concept presented here is based on predetermined teaching allocations for the participating disciplines. This necessitated selecting topics and determining the depth in which they were covered according to their relevance and potential for integration. Topics that were considered relevant from the perspective of an individual discipline but offered insufficient scope for feasible interdisciplinary integration or had limited relevance to practice were not included in iSTRANG. Such content therefore needs to be covered elsewhere in the curriculum and, where appropriate, by other disciplines. At present, no consensus curriculum for BSc Midwifery Science programmes is available, for example at national level. Consequently, decisions on the allocation and reallocation of content are discussed and coordinated locally through various structures. In addition to the iSTRANG steering group and the Curriculum Committee, this involves the leads of all modules, for example at the annual teaching conferences.
The development and maintenance of the integrated track, the preparation of teaching materials specifically tailored to the format, and training for teaching staff require substantial time and personnel resources. These requirements and the resulting costs therefore need to be taken into account when implementing this concept.
The decline in evaluation participation from an initial 80% to approximately 50% in the most recent semester introduces a potential selection effect and thus represents a limitation of the present data. This decline is consistent with nationwide experience since the COVID-19 pandemic [28], [29]. Direct feedback from teaching sessions and the curriculum committee was therefore also incorporated into the further development process. In future, particularly in view of declining participation in evaluations, this process could be supplemented by qualitative approaches such as focus groups to explore student perspectives in greater depth.
In its current form, iSTRANG is designed exclusively for midwifery science students. In principle, however, the teaching concept presented here could be transferred to other health sciences degree programmes or implemented as an interprofessional teaching format. The principal limitations are likely to relate less to the teaching content itself than to structural and organisational factors, such as semester structures, cohort sizes and available teaching time.
5. Conclusions
During the transition to fully university-based midwifery education in Germany, locally developed and evaluated curricula have an important role in guiding future practice. The model approach described here provides an empirically evaluated framework that can support other institutions in translating the statutory requirements of the HebStPrV into educationally appropriate curricula. As an iteratively developed teaching format, iSTRANG provides a practice-oriented model for developing integrated, interdisciplinary teaching formats that foster foundational competencies in the sciences and facilitate the early transfer of theory into practice in Midwifery Science degree programmes. The format demonstrates high levels of acceptance and consistently positive learning outcomes. It could also be transferred to other degree programmes or implemented as an interprofessional teaching format. However, institution-specific conditions and the curricular time required necessitate both local adaptations and adequate funding and may therefore limit implementation.
Notes
Ethical considerations
The data presented are derived from routinely conducted teaching evaluations and were analysed in anonymised form. They do not include any patient data or clinical examination findings.
Authors’ ORCIDs
- Birgit-Christiane Zyriax: [0000-0002-5377-5956]
- Louisa Kerschke: [0009-0000-9791-5490]
- Janne Schmittinger: [0009-0002-6532-2214]
- Lena Haarmann: [0009-0007-7202-3032]
- Andreas Guse: [0000-0002-3972-401X]
- Björn-Philipp Diercks: [0000-0002-6635-1706]
- Anna Worthmann: [0000-0002-4731-3974]
- Sonja Mohr: [0000-0002-8662-9752]
- Tobias Heinrich: [0000-0001-7091-2812]
- Desirée Loreth: [0000-0003-0827-149X]
- Alexander Peter Schwoerer: [0000-0002-6050-0045]
Acknowledgements
The authors thank all students for participating in the evaluations and for providing constructive feedback during individual discussions.
Competing interests
The authors declare that they have no competing interests.
References
[1] Plappert CF, Bauer NH, Dietze-Schwonberg K, Grieshop M, Kluge-Bischoff A, Zyriax BC, Striebich S. Academic education of midwives in Germany (part 1): Requirements for bachelor of science programmes in midwifery education. Position paper of the Midwifery Science Committee (AHW) in the DACH Association for Medical Education (GMA). GMS J Med Educ. 2024;41(3):Doc33. DOI: 10.3205/zma001688[2] Striebich S, Bauer NH, Dietze-Schwonberg K, Grieshop M, Kluge-Bischoff A, Zyriax BC, Plappert CF. Academic education of midwives in Germany (part 2): Opportunities and challenges for the further development of the profession of midwifery. Position paper of the Midwifery Science Committee (AHW) in the DACH Association for Medical Education (GMA). GMS J Med Educ. 2024;41(3):Doc32. DOI: 10.3205/zma001687
[3] Deutsche Gesellschaft für Hebammenwissenschaft e.V. Studiengänge Bachelor. Peine: Deutsche Gesellschaft für Hebammenwissenschaft. Zugänglich unter/available from: https://www.dghwi.de/studium-forschung/studiengange/
[4] International Confederation of Midwives. Essential Competencies for Midwifery Practice. International Confederation of Midwives; 2024. Zugänglich unter/available from: https://internationalmidwives.org/resources/essential-competencies-for-midwifery-practice/
[5] Sayn-Wittgenstein F. Geburtshilfe neu denken – Bericht zur Situation und Zukunft des Hebammenwesens in Deutschland. Berlin: Hans Huber; 2007.
[6] Zyriax BC, Schmittinger J, Diemert A. Hebammen in Hamburg – Aktuelle Entwicklungen und Herausforderungen. In: Fehr R, Augustin J, editors. Nachhaltige StadtGesundheit II. Neue Ziele, Wege, Initiativen. München: oekom Verlag; 2022. (Edition Nachhaltige Gesundheit in Stadt und Region; 5). p.306-314.
[7] International Confederation of Midwives (ICM). Grundlegenden Kompetenzen für die Hebammentätigkeit. Karlsruhe: ICM; 2019. Zugänglich unter/available from: https://hebammenverband.de/wp-content/uploads/2021/04/ICM-competencies-deutsch_final_web.pdf
[8] Hochschulrektorenkonferenz. Interdisziplinäre Kompetenzbildung: Fächerübergreifendes Denken und Handeln in der Lehre fördern, begleiten und feststellen. Berlin: Hochschulrektorenkonferenz; 2019. Zugänglich unter/available from: https://www.hrk-nexus.de/fileadmin/redaktion/hrk-nexus/07-Downloads/07-02-Publikationen/impulseNr.18_InterdisziplinaereKompetenzbildung.pdf
[9] Rheingans A, Soulos A, Mohr S, Meyer J, Guse AH. The Hamburg integrated medical degree program iMED. GMS J Med Educ. 2019;36(5):Doc52. DOI: 10.3205/zma001260
[10] Guse AH, Beikler T, Heydecke G, Gosau M, Kahl-Nieke B. Der erste Modellstudiengang Zahnmedizin in Deutschland – iMED DENT [iMED DENT-First in place model curriculum in dentistry in Germany]. Bundesgesundheitsblatt Gesundheitsforschung Gesundheitsschutz. 2023;66(12):1345-1352. DOI: 10.1007/s00103-023-03801-5
[11] Bender R, Bruhn N, Eisenbarth S, Lemke R, Pantke CF, Hampe W, Schwoerer AP. Integration naturwissenschaftlicher und medizinischer Grundlagen im Hamburger Modellstudiengang Zahnmedizin iMED DENT [Integration of natural sciences and basic medical subjects in the integrated dentistry program (iMED DENT) at the University of Hamburg]. Bundesgesundheitsblatt Gesundheitsforschung Gesundheitsschutz. 2023;66(12):1353-1362. DOI: 10.1007/s00103-023-03795-0
[12] Harden RM. What is a spiral curriculum? Med Teach. 1999;21(2):141-143. DOI: 10.1080/01421599979752
[13] Thomas PA, Kern DE, Hughes MT, Chen BY. Curriculum development for medical education : a six-step approach. Third edition. Baltimore: Johns Hopkins University Press; 2016.
[14] Knowles MS. The modern practice of adult education: from pedagogy to andragogy. Rev. and updated, 1st print ed. Wilton, Conn.: Association Press; 1980.
[15] Biggs J, Tang C, Kennedy G. Teaching for quality learning at university. Fifth edition. Maidenhead: Open University Press, McGraw Hill; 2022.
[16] Anderson LW, Krathwohl DR. A taxonomy for learning, teaching, and assessing: a revision of Bloom's taxonomy of educational objectives. New York: Longman; 2009. p.352.
[17] Dunlosky J, Rawson KA, Marsh EJ, Nathan MJ, Willingham DT. Improving Students' Learning With Effective Learning Techniques: Promising Directions From Cognitive and Educational Psychology. Psychol Sci Public Interest. 2013;14(1):4-58. DOI: 10.1177/1529100612453266
[18] Deutsche Gesellschaft für Hebammenwissenschaft; Deutsche Gesellschaft für Gynäkologie und Geburtshilfe, editors. S3 Leitlinie „Schwangerenvorsorge bei unkomplizierter Schwangerschaft“. AWMF-Registernummer 180-001. Zugänglich unter/available from: https://register.awmf.org/de/leitlinien/detail/180-001
[19] Janke TM, Makarova N, Schmittinger J, Agricola CJ, Ebinghaus M, Blome C, Zyriax BC. Women's needs and expectations in midwifery care - Results from the qualitative MiCa (midwifery care) study. Part 1: Preconception and pregnancy. Heliyon. 2024;10(4):e25862. DOI: 10.1016/j.heliyon.2024.e25862
[20] Cohen BH. Explaining Psychological Statistics. New York: John Wiley & Sons; 2003.
[21] Eisenbarth S, Tilling T, Lueerss E, Meyer J, Sehner S, Guse AH, Guse Nee Kurré J. Exploring the value and role of integrated supportive science courses in the reformed medical curriculum iMED: a mixed methods study. BMC Med Educ. 2016;16:132. DOI: 10.1186/s12909-016-0646-9
[22] Groene OR, Knorr M, Vogel D, Hild C, Hampe W. Reliability and validity of new online selection tests for midwifery students. Midwifery. 2022;106:103245. DOI: 10.1016/j.midw.2021.103245
[23] Gröne OR, Knorr M, Diemert A, Zyriax BC, Vogel D. Hamburger Auswahlverfahren zum Studium Hebammenwissenschaft: Vielfalt und Fairness fördern. Dtsch Hebammen Z. 2024;76 (1):38-42.
[24] Eisenbarth S, Urbanowicz T, Extra I, Pohlmann S, Laatsch A, Guse J, Guse A. Bedarfserhebung und Entwicklung neuer Angebote für Studienanfänger der Medizin mit Schwierigkeiten im Zugang zu den grundlegenden Naturwissenschaften [Bericht über Forschungsergebnisse]. In: Jahrestagung der Gesellschaft für Medizinische Ausbildung (GMA). Wien, 19.-22.09.2018. Düsseldorf: German Medical Science GMS Publishing House; 2018. DocP08.5. DOI: 10.3205/18gma253
[25] Fraser KL, Ayres P, Sweller J. Cognitive Load Theory for the Design of Medical Simulations. Simul Healthc. 2015;10(5):295-307. DOI: 10.1097/SIH.0000000000000097
[26] Sweller J, van Merrienboer JJ, Paas FG. Cognitive Architecture and Instructional Design. Educ Psychol Rev. 1998;10(3):251-296. DOI: 10.1023/A:1022193728205
[27] Zyriax BC, Schwoerer AP, Guse AH. Fallbeisiele und Grundlagen aus der Prävention, Biochemie und Physiologie. In: Zyriax BC, editor. Schwangerschaft und Stillzeit. München: Elsevier GmbH; 2024. p.7-47.
[28] Paulmann V, Tsikas S, Dauer K, Hunold S, Brandt M, Fischer V. Die Entwicklung der Rücklaufquoten in der Lehrevaluation – eine 10-Jahresanalyse anhand ausgewählter Studiengänge an einer medizinischen Hochschule. In: Gesellschaft für Medizinische Ausbildung (GMA), editor. Jahrestagung der Gesellschaft für Medizinische Ausbildung (GMA). Osnabrück: 14.-16.09.2023. Düsseldorf: German Medical Science GMS Publishing House; 2023. DocV-30-03. DOI: 10.3205/23gma158
[29] Schiekirka-Schwake S, Barth J, Pfeilschifter J, Hickel R, Raupach T, Herrmann-Lingen C. National survey of evaluation practices and performance-guided resource allocation at German medical schools. Ger Med Sci. 2019;17:Doc04. DOI: 10.3205/000270



